Social Security Disability Resource Center
Overview | How to Qualify | Applications
Requirements | How long it takes | Back Pay
Mental Disability | What is a disability? | Tips
SSI Benefits | How to Win | Disability Awards
Hearings | Appeals | List of Disabling Conditions
Can the Social Security Office give you Bad Advice on a Disability Claim?
Continued from: Social Security Disability Advice from the Wrong Sources
The answer to this question is, unfortunately, absolutely Yes. But, first, let's recap what was previously mentioned.
As mentioned on the page preceding this one, a person who was thinking about applying for disability was told by his psychiatrist that he was not disabled and that he should consider looking for a new type of employment.
This advice, of course, was entirely faulty. The majority of physicians and psychiatrists (conservatively speaking, 99.9999 percent) have no clue as to how disability cases are determined. More specifically, they are completely unaware of the fact that the decision on an SSD or SSI disability claim is not just a medical decision, but, rather a medical and vocational determination that weighs an individual's likelihood of being able to return to their past work. It also evaluates the likelihood of a person being able to do some type of other work.
The Social security administration oversees a disability claim system which accepts the supposition that it will be more difficult for some individuals to find some new type of employment. And this is a very reasonable position to take since some jobs that might utilize a person's inventory of work skills might not exist in their region (they may exist many states away, or may be in the process of becoming less available due to outsourcing abroad).
Additionally, for someone who is an older individual, there will always be the spectre of an employer preferring to hire a younger individual who can be paid less and who might be many years away from a higher frequency of filing health insurance claims.
In short, most doctors have no understanding of how the social security disability and SSI process works. And, therefore, they are completely unqualified when it comes to being able to discern whether or not a claimant qualifies for disability benefits.
Now, what happened when this same individual when he contacted the social security administration? He asked the social security employee whether or not he would qualify for disability. The employee asked him "Can you work?". He responded "I've been a computer programmer for most of my career, but I guess I could flip burgers". She responded "Then you're not disabled".
This was an inferior answer to the question for many reasons. However, let's start with the fact that the individuals who answer the phones within social security offices are not the people who determine eligibility on disability claims. That function is performed by disability examiners who work at a completely separate agency known as DDs, or disability determination services. The only individuals within a social security field office who "might" be qualified to even address the question "Will I qualify for disability?" are the claims representative who actually do the intake for both retirement and disability claims.
However, even these individuals are not qualified to answer the question. Why? Because they do not work on disability claims either. They only take them...and then send them on to DDS where they can be assigned to a disability examiner who will obtain the necessary evidence and then consult with medical and psychological experts in order to arrive at a decision.
To the point, social security employees who work at social security offices are not qualified to answer such questions because this is not actually part of their job, despite the fact that social security offices are where disability applications get taken. If this particular social security employee had known anything about how disability cases are determined, she would have realized that being eligible for disability benefits involves a medical and vocational decision that involves assessing the following:
1. Whether or not a person's mental or physical condition is severe.
2. Whether or not the condition, or conditions, will last at least one full year.
3. Whether or not the condition will be severe enough, with regard to the limitations that it causes, to prevent a return to one's past work.
4. Whether or not the condition will be severe enough, with regard to the limitations that is causes, to prevent the individual from being being able to switch to some type of work, given consideration of the individual's age, education, and training.
5. Whether or not the individual, assuming they could work, would be able to work (given their limitations) at a level that would earn them a substantial and gainful wage.
The social security employee who responded with "Then you're not disabled" surely did not understand the various concepts that underlie the social security definition of disability. She did not know a claimant's residual functional capacity or RFC is rated, and what determines whether or not a person can be considered able to do some type of new work, based on ther age and other factors. She most likely also did not understand the concept of substantial gainful activity which allows a person to work and be considered disabled if they lack the ability to earn more than a certain minimum amout (which is entirely fair: if a person can only work and earn $300 per month, should they really be considered fully functional and able to support themselves?).
The social security employee was unaware of all these things. And for that reason she should never have responded to the question in that manner. A better, more helpful response would have been "If you feel you are disabled, a disability application can be taken in this office, but the decision will be made by a disability examiner at a state agency that will review your medical and work history information".
So...can you receive bad advice and information from the social security office? You certainly can.
Social Security Disability and SSI Resource Center
The Most Basic questions about Getting Disability Benefits
Social Security Disability SSI and whether or not you can work
Common Mistakes to avoid after being denied for Disability
Social Security Disability SSI Questions and Answers
More Social Security Disability SSI Questions and Answers
Common Questions about Social Security Disability and SSI
Winning Social Security Disability or SSI Benefits
The SSI Disability Benefits Program
Medical exams for disability claims
Applying for Disability in various states
Social Security Disability SSI and Doctors - Yours and Theirs
Social Security Disability and SSI Claim Reviews
Social Security Disability SSI System and Benefits for Children
Denials, Appeals, and Getting a Disability Lawyer or Representative
What you should know about Social Security Disability and SSI Denials
Questions about Disability Lawyers and Hiring a Disability Attorney
Frequently asked questions about getting Denied for Disability Benefits
FAQ on Disability Claim Representation
Disability hearings before Judges
Selecting and hiring Disability Lawyers
Various Types of Benefits including SSI, Mental, and Child benefits
Social Security and SSI based on Mental Disability
Social Security Disability or SSI Benefits for Children
Disability Benefits through Social Security
Filing for Social Security Disability or SSI Benefits
Social Security Disability SSI: Medical Evidence and Records
Filing your claim for disability benefits
Eligibility for receiving disability benefits
Info about Social Security Disability Approvals and Being Approved
FAQ on Social Security Disability SSI decisions
The SSD SSI Decision Process and what gets taken into consideration
Resources on this site
Social Security Disability, SSI Terms and Definitions
Previously answered questions regarding SSD and SSI
About the Author of SSDRC, Tim Moore
For Individuals living in North Carolina
Applying for Disability in North Carolina
North Carolina Disability Lawyer
Tips for Getting Disability Approved When you File with Social Security
Tips on how to file for disability
Social Security Disability Tips — how a claim gets worked on
Tips to Prepare for Filing for Social Security Disability or SSI
What should you say if you go to a Social Security Exam?
Always list all your various symptoms on your Disability Application
List every medical condition, physical or mental, when you file for disability
Never minimize your pain or other symptoms because this can be used against you
Be ready for your disability application before the process even starts
A Tip for Making a Request for a Disability Hearing
Social Security Disability Advice from the Wrong Sources
Can the Social Security Office give you Bad Advice on a Disability Claim?
Financial Help When You Are Filing For Disability
If you apply for disability in Maryland
Will I qualify for disability benefits in Maryland?
Getting a Disability Lawyer in Maryland
These pages answer some of the most basic questions for individuals who are considering filing a claim.
How to Apply for Disability - What medical conditions can you apply and qualify for?
Applying for Disability - How long does it take to get Social Security Disability or SSI benefits?
What happens if I file a disability application and it is denied by a disability examiner or Judge?
How to Prove you are disabled and qualify to win disability benefits
How do you prove your disability case if you have a mental condition or impairment?
Social Security Disability Back pay and How Long it Takes to Qualify for it and receive it
Social Security Disability SSI - Eligibility Requirements and Qualifications Criteria