Social Security Disability and Getting a Different Diagnosis on a Mental Condition
Someone wrote in and stated that she had received different labeling of her condition (different diagnoses) after being seen by a number of different psychologists and, perhaps, M.D.s as well. Her questions were A) why does this occur and B) do disability examiners notice this in the medical records they read and, if so, how does it affect their evaluation of a case.
1. What kind of Mental Problems Qualify for Disability?.
2. How to prove and win disability with a mental condition.
As to why it happens, I think that's really part and parcel of the mental diagnostic process and the fact that mental conditions are subjective, both for the individuals who suffer with their conditions and for those who must attempt to properly categorize their condition for the purpose of delivering proper and effective treatment.
In my own experiences in assisting others in mental health settings (this would not be in the capacity of an examiner), I've found that it is fairly common to received different--and sometimes even dissimilar diagnoses--from different psychiatrists and psychologists. For example, patient A could receive treatment from Doctor A and then, for whatever reason, switch to Doctor B. Doctor B, after performing his or her own evaluation of the patient may determine the prior diagnosis was incorrect, or perhaps that the patient's condition has changed in some way that affects the current diagnosis. Sometimes, this means dropping the old diagnosis in favor of a different one, or adding a new diagnosis to the current list of diagnosed conditions.
This is fairly routine and normal, based on my experience as an examiner, but also from my own personal observations taken within the mental health system.
However, it does lend some insight as to why mental health disability claims sometimes have an uphill battle.
As I've said many times, the process of making a decision on a disability claim is highly subjective. If that wasn't true, then certainly would not have so many individuals being denied at the first appeal level (request for reconsideration), with such a high percentage of those denials effectively being overturned by federal judges at Social Security Disability hearings.
Also, there is the fact that (and I base this on my own direct experience as an examiner) a case could be taken to several different processing units at a disability determination services agency (where disability claims get worked on for the social security administration) and you could literally get back more than one type of decision. Meaning the system is subjective and not so objective as many would pretend is the case. And it becomes more subjective with mental claims, particularly when you consider the fact that, so often, treating mental health professionals cannot even agree on a diagnosis.
As to the second question: how do disability examiners deal with this phenomenon? Actually, quite easily. Because, as I've said many times on this blog and on www.ssdrc.com, it is not the diagnosis, not the name of the condition that everything rests on. All Social Security Disability and SSI cases are decided according to the functional limitations that are demonstrated by the claimant's medical records. And cases are approved if those records indicate the claimant cannot return to their past relevant work or perform some type of other work while earning a substantial and gainful income. To a large degree in most cases, the name of the condition itself is barely relevant.
About the Author: Tim Moore is a former Social Security Disability Examiner in North Carolina, has been interviewed by the NY Times and the LA Times on the disability system, and is an Accredited Disability Representative (ADR) in North Carolina. For assistance on a disability application or Appeal in NC, click here.
Most popular topics on SSDRC.com
Social Security Disability in North Carolina
Common Mistakes to avoid after being denied for Disability
Tips to Prepare for Filing for Social Security Disability or SSI
Advice to Win SSD and SSI Benefit Claims
Social Security Disability SSI Questions
What is the difference between Social Security Disability and SSI?
How to get disability for depression
Getting disability for fibromyalgia
SSI disability for children with ADHD
What is the Application Process for Social Security Disability and SSI?
Social Security Disability SSI Exam tips
More Social Security Disability SSI Questions
What makes you eligible for Social Security Disability or SSI?
Who is eligible for SSI, how do I apply?
How to File for SSI
Permanent disability benefits
Disability requirements, eligibility, criteria
Disability requirements and how to file in Illinois
Applying for disability, medical conditions
How do you Apply for SSI?
What medical conditions get you approved for disability?
Social Security Disability qualifications
How to claim disability benefits
What medical conditions do they Award Disability Benefits for?